Skip to content

Shop Staff's Handpicked Birthday Collection

Search

Menu

SHOP
NEW & COOL
SHOP IN-STORE
GIFT CARD
BALLOONS
ABOUT

Home
Gift Guide

Gift Guide

(161 products)

We've curated our most loved picks to help you find something exceptional for every kid on your list—from thoughtful little finds to standout pieces they'll never forget. Whether you're shopping for curious toddlers, creative tweens, or hard-to-impress teens, our Gift Guide takes the guesswork out of finding toys worth giving. 🎁

Sort by

Most relevant
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low

FiltersFilter & Sort

Applied Filters

Clear all

Sort by

Most relevant
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low

Recommended Age Group

Baby (0-1) (7)
Toddler (2-3) (29)
Little Kid (4-7) (54)
Big Kid (8+) (61)
Adult (9)

Clear

Tween & Teen

Tween & Teen (54)

Clear

Price

From $

-

To $

From To

Clear

Brand

Clear

Alpine Arts Center
Coloring Telluride Book - artist Lauren Merrill

Regular price $14⁹⁹
Hotaling Imports, Inc.
Liontouch Foam Sword

Regular price $12⁹⁹
Green Gal Creative
The Wheels on the Goose

Regular price $25⁹⁵
Sold out
Incredible Group
The Incredible Silent B-Ball

Regular price $20⁹⁹
Winning Moves
Scattergories - The Card Game

Regular price $10²⁰
Sold out
Little Kids
Grabits Gripimals

Regular price $14⁹⁹
Ahava River Publications
Colorado Nature and Wildlife Coloring Activity Book (featuring Telluride)

Regular price $17⁹⁹
Asmodee
Catan

Regular price $74⁹⁹
Winning Moves
Clue Suspect Card Game

Regular price $9⁹⁹
Bruder Toys
BRUDER CAT assortment

Regular price From $30⁹⁹
Continuum Games
Farkle! Fun Cup & Dice

Regular price $14⁹⁹
Project Genius
True Genius Lock & Key Puzzles

Regular price $17⁹⁹
Schylling Toys
Plush Finger Puppets

Regular price $6⁹⁹
Aurora World Inc
5" Hunk Hippo

Regular price $10⁴⁹
Sold out
Blue Orange Games USA
FootzyBall

Regular price $18⁹⁹
A-B-Skis LLC
A-B Skis

Regular price $29⁹⁹
Enchanted Forest Toy Shoppe
Telluride 1-2-3

Regular price $29⁹⁹
Snifty Scented Products
Sketch Studio B & W Travel Set

Regular price $28⁹⁹
Fat Brain Toys
Air Toobz

Regular price $193⁹⁹
Sold out
U.S. Toy Co
Press And Go Carrot Car

Regular price $5⁹⁹
Continuum Games
Uno: Flip Card Game

Regular price $12⁹⁹
Winning Moves
Risk - The 1980's Edition

Regular price $42⁹⁹
Sold out
New arrival
Spin Master
Aerobie Pro Ring 14"

Regular price $13⁴⁹
New arrival
Spin Master
Hex Bots Skitter Bot Spider

Regular price $18⁹⁹
Sold out
Fat Brain Toys
Air Toobz Whirlwind Accessory Pack

Regular price $29⁹⁹
U.S. Toy Co
Transportation Sticker Book

Regular price $10⁹⁹
Crocodile Creek
Coloring Stickers/Unicorn

Regular price $17⁹⁹
Fizz Creations
Pac-Man Desktop Arcade

Regular price $35⁹⁹
Brightz
Horn Brightz - Pink

Regular price $9⁴⁹
GAMEWRIGHT/CEACO
Slamwich Card Game

Regular price $22⁹⁹
New arrival
Spin Master
Rubik's Phantom Cube

Regular price $29⁴⁹
U.S. Toy Co
Jumpsies Rope

Regular price $3⁹⁹

Green Pink Orange
Fat Brain Toys
Ivan's Hinge

Regular price $17⁹⁹
Marky Sparky Toys
Doinkit Darts

Regular price $34⁹⁹
ACD Toys Games
Rummikub in Original Retro Tin

Regular price $55⁹⁹
Continuum Games
Apples to Apples Party in a Box

Regular price $31⁹⁹
Continuum Games
Crazy 8s w Important Dates

Regular price $8⁴⁹
Winning Moves
Pass The Pigs - Pig Party Edition

Regular price $27⁹⁹
Fat Brain Toys
Tiltago Keychain

Regular price $6⁹⁹

Blue Green Red
iScream
Do Not Disturb Furry Journal

Regular price $17⁹⁹
Fat Brain Toys
Air Toobzters (5 pack)

Regular price $16⁹⁹
New arrival
Manhattan Toy
Click-Clack Colorpop

Regular price $23⁹⁹
Crocodile Creek
Sparkle Scratch Art/Unicorn

Regular price $17⁹⁹
Valtech - magnatiles
Magna-Tiles Forest Animals 25-Piece Set

Regular price $55⁹⁹
New arrival
Spin Master
Italian Brainrot Mystery Trading Cards

Regular price $11⁴⁹
Sold out

Bruder Toys
BRUDER MB Snowplow

Regular price $57⁹⁹
New arrival
Masterpieces Puzzles
Smokey the Bear Playing Cards

Regular price $9⁹⁹
Sold out
Duncan
Pulse Light-Up Yo-Yo

Regular price $20⁴⁹
Continuum Games
Mad Libs: The Game

Regular price $29⁹⁹
Melissa & Doug
Super Smile Dentist Play Set

Regular price $49⁴⁹

Previous
Page 1 / 4
1
2
3
4
Next

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Subtotal:$0⁰⁰ USD

Loading...

Contact Us

Enchanted Forest Toy Shoppe
150 W. Pacific Ave., Unit C
Telluride, CO 81435
(970) 239-6112

Summer Hours
Monday - Saturday
11AM-6PM
Sunday
12PM-5PM

info@eftoyshoppe.com

A heartfelt thank you for choosing to shop small. Independent toy stores need your support to continue doing what we love—bringing joy, discovery, and imagination to the children in our community.

We pour our hearts into every recommendation, every carefully curated shelf. Every visit, every purchase, every kind word matters.

Facebook
Instagram

Quick Links

Balloons
Contact
The Wonder Club
My Account

Policies

Refund Policy
Shipping Policy
Terms of Service
Privacy Policy
Contact Information

Join our Mailing List

Sign up for exclusive offers, events and more.

Email

Payment methods accepted

© 2026 Enchanted Forest Toy Shoppe.

© 2026 Website by Co-Creative Solutions, LLC